#e4mXplains: Why broadcasters are seeking protection from liability over third-party ad claims
Broadcasters say they can reasonably be expected to check whether an ad is suitable for broadcast, meets applicable content-related requirements and identifies the principal advertiser or agency
by
Published: Nov 17, 2026 8:47 AM | 4 min read
- The broadcasting sector has expressed concerns regarding the revised Draft Telecommunications Rules, which link Advertising Code compliance to broadcasting authorizations, raising questions about the extent of broadcasters' responsibility for third-party advertisement claims.
- Broadcasters argue they should verify the suitability of advertisements but not independently validate every factual claim, as they may lack the necessary data or expertise.
- The sector advocates for a clear distinction between the broadcaster's role and the responsibilities of advertisers, emphasizing that accountability for claims should rest with the entity that originates them.
- Broadcasters seek amendments to ensure that violations related to third-party claims do not affect their authorizations if they have exercised reasonable due diligence, arguing that the current framework risks unfairly penalizing them for claims beyond their control.
The broadcasting sector has raised concerns over the revised Draft Telecommunications (Television, Radio and Associated Services) Rules, 2026, which link Advertising Code compliance to broadcasting authorisations. The question is how far a broadcaster should be responsible for claims in third-party advertisements.
Broadcasters argue that they can reasonably be expected to check whether an advertisement is suitable for broadcast, meets applicable content-related requirements and identifies the principal advertiser or agency. However, they say this should not extend to independently verifying every factual claim made about a product or service.
Claims may relate to a product’s features, performance, efficacy or benefits. Broadcasters say they may not have the underlying data, technical expertise or infrastructure to test each assertion independently.
The sector says the entity making a commercial claim is best placed to substantiate it.
Why does the draft matter?
The revised Draft Rules propose making compliance with the Advertising Code part of the authorisation framework. Broadcasters are concerned that a violation relating to the accuracy of a third-party claim could have consequences beyond the advertisement itself, including implications for the validity or renewal of an authorisation.
They say this could expose broadcasters to consequences for information originating with advertisers or agencies and outside their reasonable control.
An executive from the broadcasting sector, speaking on condition of anonymity, said: “Broadcasters can review an advertisement against applicable broadcast requirements, but cannot be expected to independently verify every product claim. The advertiser is the source of that claim and should be responsible for substantiating it.”
What responsibility should broadcasters carry?
The sector is not seeking to remove broadcasters’ responsibility, but wants obligations to reflect their role.
Broadcasters may be required to exercise reasonable due diligence before an advertisement is aired. This could include checking its suitability for broadcast, complying with content-placement requirements and identifying the principal advertiser or agency.
However, they argue that responsibility for substantiating claims should rest with the advertiser, agency, manufacturer or service provider that makes or supplies them, particularly where the broadcaster has no reasonable means of independent verification.
Another senior broadcasting executive said: “There must be a distinction between checking whether an advertisement can be carried and certifying the truth of every statement in it. Broadcasters do not manufacture the products or generate the evidence behind the claims.”
What is the safe-harbour argument?
Broadcasters have referred to principles underlying the safe-harbour framework under the Information Technology Act, drawing an analogy with assessing responsibilities according to an entity’s role and expected due diligence.
For broadcasters, this means undertaking reasonable due diligence and complying with applicable obligations relating to advertisement placement and carriage. They should not be held responsible for the substantive accuracy of claims they are not reasonably equipped to verify, provided they have carried out the required checks and can identify the principal advertiser or agency.
The reference is to principles underlying safe harbour; it is not a claim that broadcasters automatically receive the same statutory protection as intermediaries under the Information Technology Act.
Why is identifying the advertiser important?
Identifying the principal advertiser or agency would distinguish the broadcaster’s carriage role from the responsibility of the entity originating the claim.
The sector argues that accountability should rest with the participant best positioned to produce supporting evidence and establish the claim’s accuracy. It says this would create a clearer allocation of responsibility without removing reasonable checks by broadcasters.
A third senior broadcasting-sector executive said: “If a broadcaster has undertaken due diligence and can identify the advertiser, it should not face authorisation-related action merely because a third-party claim is later found to be inaccurate. Responsibility should follow control over the claim and the evidence supporting it.”
What change are broadcasters seeking?
Broadcasters want the final Rules to recognise the distinct roles of participants in the advertising ecosystem and ensure that consequences for Advertising Code violations are proportionate. They have sought clarity that violations arising from the substantive accuracy of third-party commercial claims should not, by themselves, affect an authorisation or its renewal where the broadcaster has exercised reasonable due diligence and met its applicable obligations.
The issue is where responsibility for verifying commercial claims should lie, and whether broadcasters should face authorisation-related consequences for claims they cannot reasonably validate.
Broadcasters state that the revised framework does not appear to have fully addressed an earlier concern that liability under the Advertising Code should be calibrated to the respective roles and capabilities of participants.
Broadcasters say linking the Code to authorisation conditions risks turning third-party claims into a matter affecting their regulatory standing, even after reasonable due diligence.
Read more news about Television Media, Digital Media, Advertising India, Marketing News, PR and Corporate Communication News
For more updates, be socially connected with us onInstagram, LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook YouTube & Google News
